Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav (Compare Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav)
So many brokers are offering stock trading & Demat services in India, which one is best, which one provides the services at the lowest price, provides best mobile trading application, the best research team, etc. All answers to your questions would be available here.
Here we provide side by side comparison between Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav, Below comparison of Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav highlights the variations of Brokerage charges & services offered, Compare their ratings, brokerage & AMC charges, Investment choices, Customer Service, Demat Account, features, Platforms, and running offers.
Check reviews of other Share brokers
One on One comparison of Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav is given below:
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
| About The Brokers |
Edelweiss :
"Edelweiss is one of the best brokerage houses that not just offers broking services but also offers you advisory and research facilities at extremely competitive pric >>> more
|
Mangal Keshav :
Mangal Keshav was started in 1939 and since then dedicatedly working towards serving their customers. They have evolved their working accor >>> more
|
| Find More Information about the Broker : |
Edelweiss :
OVERVIEW
BROKERAGE
PRODUCTS & SERVICES
TRADING PLATFORM & TOOLS
RATING
|
Mangal Keshav :
OVERVIEW
BROKERAGE
PRODUCTS & SERVICES
TRADING PLATFORM & TOOLS
RATING
|
| Type of Broker |
Edelweiss :
Full Service Broker
|
Mangal Keshav :
Full Service Broker
|
| Promo/offers |
Edelweiss :
Special Offer: Flat Brokerage of ₹10/ executed order across all segments Including Equity Delivery, Intraday, F&O, and Currency F&O. Get the offer
|
Mangal Keshav :
N/A
|
| Advantage |
Edelweiss :
- Security of your investment & money.
- Top class customer service
- Award-winning research services
- Different brokerage plans for the different type of clients
- Flat Rs 10 per executed order brokerage across the trading segments.
- Facility to open Instant paperless online account.
- Online IPO investment
- Relationship managers and add-on services like PMS are available
- Free call & trade services for Edelweiss Elite Plan subscribers.
|
Mangal Keshav :
Provides NRI trading.
Strong customer support system.
PAN India presence with 365 branches.
Professional representatives for proper guidance.
Broker member of Dubai gold and Commodities Exchange (DGCX)
|
| Disadvantage |
Edelweiss :
- Bracket orders and Good-Till canceled (GTC) orders are not available.
- No 3-in-1 account facility available
- Call & Trade is available at an additional cost of ₹ 20 per call.
- ₹ 50 per month for research calls and trading tips.
- High DP charges compared to other brokers..
|
Mangal Keshav :
The broker does not provide any kind on mobile base trading.
No-proper trading plans available with the broker.
|
| Why This |
Edelweiss :
- Edelweiss Broking Limited is full-service broker who provide 2-in-1 On-line trading account to Indian as well as NRIs of gulf country.
- Award Winning Research and user-friendly trading platforms.
- They are versatile and provide the different broke plan to different types of clients.
- Edelweiss despite being a Full-service broker offer both discount & Full-service brokerage plans.
- Provide their services to Indians as well as NRIs and is very famous in Gulf countries.
- Wide offline presence through branches and franchises makes it easy for customers.
- Highly competitive brokerage plan as flat fee of ₹10 per order is comparatively cheaper than Zerodha, SAMCO and Upstox brokerage plan of ₹ 20/per order.
- Multiple trading platforms - Edelweiss Mobile Trader, Edelweiss Terminal X3 and Edelweiss.in.
|
Mangal Keshav :
Diversity in investment.
Dedicated relationship managers and experts who can help you in portfolio management.
Provide Services to NRIs.
325 business units all across states provides extensive reach to the customers.
In-depth market research and correct evaluation of market trends gives you a clear idea which stock to invest upon.
Real-time report and data. Also provides quick platform for the transactions.
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Account Opening & AMC Charges
Edelweiss Trading Account Opening Fee is ₹750
and
Mangal Keshav Trading Account Opening Fee is NULL
.
Edelweiss Demat Account AMC is ₹0 (₹300 from 2nd year)
and
Mangal Keshav Demat Account AMC is NULL
.
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Trading Account Opening Fee
|
Trading Account Opening Fee :
₹750
|
Trading Account Opening Fee :
NULL
|
|
Demat Account Opening Fee
|
Demat Account Opening Fee :
₹0
|
Demat Account Opening Fee :
NULL
|
|
Demat Account AMC
|
Demat Account AMC :
₹0 (₹300 from 2nd year)
|
Demat Account AMC :
NULL
|
|
Trading Account AMC
|
Trading Account AMC :
₹0
|
Trading Account AMC :
NULL
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Brokerage Charges
Edelweiss Brokerage Charges
Equity Delivery is ₹10 or 0.01% whichever lower
and
Equity Intraday is ₹10 or 0.01% whichever lower
and
Equity Options is ₹10.00 / executed order
.
Mangal Keshav Brokerage Charges
Equity Delivery is 0.30%
and
Equity Intraday is 0.03%
and
Equity Options is ₹100 per lot
.
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
| Plan Name |
Plan Name :
Edelweiss Lite
|
Plan Name :
Edelweiss Elite
|
Plan Name :
Prepaid Plan
|
Plan Name :
Basic Plan
|
|
Equity Delivery
|
Equity Delivery :
₹10 or 0.01% whichever lower
|
Equity Delivery :
0.300%
|
Equity Delivery :
0.10%
|
Equity Delivery :
0.30%
|
|
Equity Intraday
|
Equity Intraday :
₹10 or 0.01% whichever lower
|
Equity Intraday :
0.030%
|
Equity Intraday :
0.01%
|
Equity Intraday :
0.03%
|
|
Equity Future
|
Equity Future :
₹10 or 0.01% whichever lower
|
Equity Future :
0.030%
|
Equity Future :
0.01%
|
Equity Future :
0.03%
|
|
Equity Options
|
Equity Options :
₹10.00 / executed order
|
Equity Options :
₹90 per lot
|
Equity Options :
₹25 per lot
|
Equity Options :
₹100 per lot
|
|
Currency Futures
|
Currency Futures :
₹10 or 0.01% whichever lower
|
Currency Futures :
0.04%
|
Currency Futures :
0.01%
|
Currency Futures :
0.03%
|
|
Currency Options
|
Currency Options :
₹10.00 / executed order
|
Currency Options :
₹22 per lot
|
Currency Options :
₹6 per lot
|
Currency Options :
0.03%
|
|
Monthly Fee
|
Monthly Fee :
NA
|
Monthly Fee :
₹12,000 + ₹1,800 (Service tax) per year
|
Monthly Fee :
₹1,12,000 + ₹16,800 (Service tax) per year
|
Monthly Fee :
NULL
|
|
Margin Trading
|
Margin Trading :
-
|
Margin Trading :
-
|
Margin Trading :
-
|
Margin Trading :
-
|
|
Commodity Futures
|
Commodity Futures :
-
|
Commodity Futures :
-
|
Commodity Futures :
-
|
Commodity Futures :
-
|
|
Commodity Options
|
Commodity Options :
-
|
Commodity Options :
-
|
Commodity Options :
-
|
Commodity Options :
-
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Transaction Charges (Per Crore)
Edelweiss Transaction Charges (Per Crore)
Equity Future is NSE ₹190 | BSE ₹190
and
Equity Options is NSE ₹5000 | BSE ₹5000
.
Mangal Keshav Transaction Charges (Per Crore)
Equity Future is ₹190 Per Cr
and
Equity Options is ₹5000 Per Cr
.
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Equity Delivery
|
Equity Delivery :
NSE ₹325 | BSE ₹275
|
Equity Delivery :
₹325 Per Cr
|
|
Equity Intraday
|
Equity Intraday :
NSE ₹325 | BSE ₹275
|
Equity Intraday :
₹325 Per Cr
|
|
Equity Future
*
|
Equity Future :
NSE ₹190 | BSE ₹190
|
Equity Future :
₹190 Per Cr
|
|
Equity Options
*
|
Equity Options :
NSE ₹5000 | BSE ₹5000
|
Equity Options :
₹5000 Per Cr
|
|
Currency Futures
*
|
Currency Futures :
NSE ₹115 | BSE ₹115
|
Currency Futures :
₹110 Per Cr
|
|
Currency Options
|
Currency Options :
₹4000
|
Currency Options :
₹4000 Per Cr
|
|
Commodity
|
Commodity :
-
|
Commodity :
-
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Other Charges
Edelweiss
Minimum Brokerage is ₹10 or 0.01% whichever lower
and
Call & Trade is ₹20
.
Mangal Keshav
Minimum Brokerage is Null
and
Call & Trade is Null
.
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Minimum Brokerage
|
Minimum Brokerage :
₹10 or 0.01% whichever lower
|
Minimum Brokerage :
Null
|
|
Call & Trade
|
Call & Trade :
₹20
|
Call & Trade :
Null
|
|
Stamp Duty
*
|
Stamp Duty :
Depends on state
|
Stamp Duty :
Charges as per the state of residence
|
|
DP Charges (on sell side)
|
DP Charges (on sell side) :
-
|
DP Charges (on sell side) :
Null
|
|
Other Miscellaneous Charges
|
Other Miscellaneous Charges :
-
|
Other Miscellaneous Charges :
-
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Features
Edelweiss
and
Mangal Keshav
both
offer a host of features, trading tools & platforms to their clients. Their comparative analysis is in the below table:
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Trading Platform
|
Trading Platform :
Edelweiss Mobile Trader, Trading Website and TX3 Trading Terminal
|
Trading Platform :
ODIN Diet
|
|
Placing orders through charts
|
Placing orders through charts :
-
|
Placing orders through charts :
-
|
|
Trading Alerts
|
Trading Alerts :
Yes
|
Trading Alerts :
-
|
|
Research and Advice / Trading Tips
|
Research and Advice / Trading Tips :
Yes
|
Research and Advice / Trading Tips :
Yes
|
|
Detailed Education Initiatives
|
Detailed Education Initiatives :
Yes
|
Detailed Education Initiatives :
No
|
|
Unique features & Offers
|
Unique features & Offers :
-
|
Unique features & Offers :
-
|
|
Referral Program
|
Referral Program :
-
|
Referral Program :
-
|
|
Margin Against Shares (Equity Cash)
*
|
Margin Against Shares (Equity Cash) :
Yes
|
Margin Against Shares (Equity Cash) :
Yes
|
|
Margin Against Shares (Equity F&O)
*
|
Margin Against Shares (Equity F&O) :
Yes
|
Margin Against Shares (Equity F&O) :
Yes
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Demat Account Charges
A comparative table of various demat account charges between
Edelweiss
and
Mangal Keshav
is below:
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Depository Service Provider
|
Depository Service Provider :
NSDL
|
Depository Service Provider :
CDSL & NSDL
|
|
Account Opening Fee
|
Account Opening Fee :
₹0
|
Account Opening Fee :
NIL
|
|
Advance Deposit
|
Advance Deposit :
Nil
|
Advance Deposit :
Deposit Scheme? ₹1000/- where AMC will not be charged and amount will be refundable at Time of Closure of demat account. If the account is closed prior to one year deposit amount will not be refunded.
|
|
AMC
|
AMC :
₹0 (₹300 2nd year onward)
|
AMC :
Scheme A: ₹750/- Individual Scheme B: ₹199/- Individual Scheme C: ₹500/- NRI Scheme D:₹199/- Plus CDSL Charges for Corporate
|
|
Dematerialisation Charges
|
Dematerialisation Charges :
₹2 per certificate + ₹30 for postage
|
Dematerialisation Charges :
₹ 150/- Inclusive of Courier Charges + ₹ 100/- Per Certificate
|
|
Rematerialisation Charges
|
Rematerialisation Charges :
₹10 per 100 securities+ ₹30 for postage
|
Rematerialisation Charges :
Upfront ₹ 150/- plus CDSL Charges Inclusive of Courier Charges + ₹ 100/- Per Certificate
|
|
Transaction Charges (Credit)
|
Transaction Charges (Credit) :
-
|
Transaction Charges (Credit) :
-
|
|
Transaction Charges (debit)
|
Transaction Charges (debit) :
-
|
Transaction Charges (debit) :
0.05% On the Value of the Debit Transactions with Minimum ₹100/-
|
|
Pledge Creation Charges
|
Pledge Creation Charges :
₹50 per transaction
|
Pledge Creation Charges :
Charge Charged By the Depository + 0.02% On the Value of the Application
|
|
Pledge Creation Confirmation Charges
|
Pledge Creation Confirmation Charges :
₹50 per transaction
|
Pledge Creation Confirmation Charges :
NIL
|
|
Pledge Invocation Charges
|
Pledge Invocation Charges :
₹25 per transaction
|
Pledge Invocation Charges :
Charge Charged By the Depository + 0.02% On the Value of the Application
|
|
Failed Instruction Charges
|
Failed Instruction Charges :
-
|
Failed Instruction Charges :
NIL
|
|
Other Charges
|
Other Charges :
-
|
Other Charges :
NIL
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Basic Details
Edelweiss
Year of Incorporation is 2008
and
Total Number of Clients is 183089
and
Total Number of Branches is 475+
.
Mangal Keshav
Year of Incorporation is 1939
and
Total Number of Clients is 7503
and
Total Number of Branches is 325+ locations
.
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Year of Incorporation
|
Year of Incorporation :
2008
|
Year of Incorporation :
1939
|
|
Active Exchange Memberships
|
Active Exchange Memberships :
NSE, BSE, MCX
|
Active Exchange Memberships :
NSE, BSE, MCX, NCDEX
|
|
Demat Services
|
Demat Services :
NSDL
|
Demat Services :
CDSL & NSDL
|
|
Website
|
Website :
www.edelweiss.in
|
Website :
www.mangalkeshav.com/
|
|
Contact Details
|
Contact Details :
1800-102-3335
|
Contact Details :
+91 22 6190 8000
|
|
Total Number of Clients
|
Total Number of Clients :
183089
|
Total Number of Clients :
7503
|
|
Total Number of Branches
|
Total Number of Branches :
475+
|
Total Number of Branches :
325+ locations
|
|
Products
*
|
Products :
-
|
Products :
-
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Leverage
Leverage
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Equity Delivery
|
Equity Delivery :
-
|
Equity Delivery :
-
|
|
Equity Intraday
|
Equity Intraday :
-
|
Equity Intraday :
-
|
|
Equity Futures
|
Equity Futures :
-
|
Equity Futures :
-
|
|
Equity Options
|
Equity Options :
-
|
Equity Options :
-
|
|
Currency Futures
|
Currency Futures :
-
|
Currency Futures :
-
|
|
Currency Options
|
Currency Options :
-
|
Currency Options :
-
|
|
Commodity Futures
|
Commodity Futures :
-
|
Commodity Futures :
-
|
|
Commodity Options
|
Commodity Options :
-
|
Commodity Options :
-
|
|
F&O (Eq, Curr, Comm)
|
F&O (Eq, Curr, Comm) :
-
|
F&O (Eq, Curr, Comm) :
-
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Orders
Orders
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Cover Orders (CO)
|
Cover Orders (CO) :
Yes
|
Cover Orders (CO) :
-
|
|
Bracket orders / One Cancels Other (BO / OCO)
|
Bracket orders / One Cancels Other (BO / OCO) :
No
|
Bracket orders / One Cancels Other (BO / OCO) :
-
|
|
After Market Orders (AMO)
|
After Market Orders (AMO) :
Yes
|
After Market Orders (AMO) :
-
|
|
Buy Today Sell Tomorrow (BTST)
*
|
Buy Today Sell Tomorrow (BTST) :
Yes
|
Buy Today Sell Tomorrow (BTST) :
Yes
|
|
Sell Today Buy Tomorrow (STBT)
*
|
Sell Today Buy Tomorrow (STBT) :
Yes
|
Sell Today Buy Tomorrow (STBT) :
Yes
|
|
Good Till Cancelled (GTC)
*
|
Good Till Cancelled (GTC) :
Yes
|
Good Till Cancelled (GTC) :
Yes
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Research and Advice / Trading Tips
Research and Advice / Trading Tips
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Equity Trading Recommendation
*
|
Equity Trading Recommendation :
-
|
Equity Trading Recommendation :
-
|
|
Equity Investment Recommendation
*
|
Equity Investment Recommendation :
-
|
Equity Investment Recommendation :
-
|
|
Recommendation basis risk Profile
*
|
Recommendation basis risk Profile :
-
|
Recommendation basis risk Profile :
-
|
|
Comparison
*
|
Comparison :
-
|
Comparison :
-
|
|
Free Tips
*
|
Free Tips :
-
|
Free Tips :
-
|
|
Daily Market report
*
|
Daily Market report :
-
|
Daily Market report :
-
|
|
ETF research
*
|
ETF research :
-
|
ETF research :
-
|
|
Quarterly Results
*
|
Quarterly Results :
-
|
Quarterly Results :
-
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Franchisee / Authorized Person related information
Franchisee / Authorized Person related information
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Availability for franchisee / AP
|
Availability for franchisee / AP :
Yes
|
Availability for franchisee / AP :
-
|
|
Investment required for Franchisee / AP
|
Investment required for Franchisee / AP :
Rs 3 to 5 lakh
|
Investment required for Franchisee / AP :
-
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Product & Services
Edelweiss
and
Mangal Keshav
both
offer a host of Products & Services for a better trading experience for their clients. Their comparative analysis is in the below table:
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Delivery Based Trading
*
|
Delivery Based Trading :
-
|
Delivery Based Trading :
-
|
|
Margin Trading
*
|
Margin Trading :
-
|
Margin Trading :
-
|
|
Call in Trade
*
|
Call in Trade :
-
|
Call in Trade :
-
|
|
Trading in Both the exchanges
*
|
Trading in Both the exchanges :
-
|
Trading in Both the exchanges :
-
|
|
Limit Order
*
|
Limit Order :
-
|
Limit Order :
-
|
|
3-in-1 On-line Trading Account
*
|
3-in-1 On-line Trading Account :
-
|
3-in-1 On-line Trading Account :
-
|
|
NRI Services
*
|
NRI Services :
-
|
NRI Services :
-
|
|
SMS Alerts
*
|
SMS Alerts :
-
|
SMS Alerts :
-
|
|
Offers Multiple Plan
*
|
Offers Multiple Plan :
-
|
Offers Multiple Plan :
-
|
|
IPO Investment
*
|
IPO Investment :
-
|
IPO Investment :
-
|
|
Portfolio Analysis
*
|
Portfolio Analysis :
-
|
Portfolio Analysis :
-
|
|
Advanced Charting Features
*
|
Advanced Charting Features :
-
|
Advanced Charting Features :
-
|
|
Brokerage Calculator
*
|
Brokerage Calculator :
-
|
Brokerage Calculator :
-
|
|
Margin Calculator
*
|
Margin Calculator :
-
|
Margin Calculator :
-
|
|
Stop Loss Order
*
|
Stop Loss Order :
-
|
Stop Loss Order :
-
|
|
Bracket Orders & Trailing Stop Loss
*
|
Bracket Orders & Trailing Stop Loss :
-
|
Bracket Orders & Trailing Stop Loss :
-
|
|
Equity Future & Option Trading
*
|
Equity Future & Option Trading :
-
|
Equity Future & Option Trading :
-
|
|
Currency Future & Option Trading
*
|
Currency Future & Option Trading :
-
|
Currency Future & Option Trading :
-
|
|
Market Trading
*
|
Market Trading :
-
|
Market Trading :
-
|
|
Monthly & Yearly Plan
*
|
Monthly & Yearly Plan :
-
|
Monthly & Yearly Plan :
-
|
|
Aumtomated Trading
*
|
Aumtomated Trading :
-
|
Aumtomated Trading :
-
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Customer Services
Edelweiss
and
Mangal Keshav
both
offer a host of Customer service options to their clients to quickly solve their queries or grievances if any. Their comparative analysis is in the below table:
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Toll Free Number
*
|
Toll Free Number :
-
|
Toll Free Number :
-
|
|
Live Chat Facility
*
|
Live Chat Facility :
-
|
Live Chat Facility :
-
|
|
Email Facility
*
|
Email Facility :
-
|
Email Facility :
-
|
|
Branch Offices
*
|
Branch Offices :
-
|
Branch Offices :
-
|
|
Customer Care
*
|
Customer Care :
-
|
Customer Care :
-
|
|
Community Service
*
|
Community Service :
-
|
Community Service :
-
|
|
Relationship Manager
*
|
Relationship Manager :
-
|
Relationship Manager :
-
|
|
24/7 Support
*
|
24/7 Support :
-
|
24/7 Support :
-
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Other Investement
Edelweiss
and
Mangal Keshav
both
offer a lot of investment avenues apart from Stock trading on their platforms to their clients to make a better trading experience. Their comparative analysis is in the below table:
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Commodity Trading
*
|
Commodity Trading :
-
|
Commodity Trading :
-
|
|
Investment in ETFs
*
|
Investment in ETFs :
-
|
Investment in ETFs :
-
|
|
Investment in Mutual Funds
*
|
Investment in Mutual Funds :
-
|
Investment in Mutual Funds :
-
|
|
Investment in Bonds
*
|
Investment in Bonds :
-
|
Investment in Bonds :
-
|
|
Investment in Corporate Debt instruments
*
|
Investment in Corporate Debt instruments :
-
|
Investment in Corporate Debt instruments :
-
|
|
Insurance Services
*
|
Insurance Services :
-
|
Insurance Services :
-
|
|
Banking Services
*
|
Banking Services :
-
|
Banking Services :
-
|
Edelweiss vs Mangal Keshav Trading PlatForm
Edelweiss
and
Mangal Keshav
both
offer a host of Trading Platform for a better trading experience for their clients. Their comparative analysis is in the below table:
|
Edelweiss
|
Mangal Keshav
|
|
Web Platform
*
|
Web Platform :
-
|
Web Platform :
-
|
|
Android Mobile App
*
|
Android Mobile App :
-
|
Android Mobile App :
-
|
|
Desktop Windows
*
|
Desktop Windows :
-
|
Desktop Windows :
-
|
|
Desktop Mac
*
|
Desktop Mac :
-
|
Desktop Mac :
-
|
|
I-Pad App
*
|
I-Pad App :
-
|
I-Pad App :
-
|
|
Virtual Trading
*
|
Virtual Trading :
-
|
Virtual Trading :
-
|
|
iPhone Mobile App
*
|
iPhone Mobile App :
-
|
iPhone Mobile App :
-
|
| Contact Now |
Enquire Now
|
Enquire Now
|
- - - Compare More Brokers - - -
0 Comments