• Top Stock Brokers in India ‐ Reviews, Comparison and Offers

IDBI Capital vs TradingBell (Compare IDBI Capital vs TradingBell)

So many brokers are offering stock trading & Demat services in India, which one is best, which one provides the services at the lowest price, provides best mobile trading application, the best research team, etc. All answers to your questions would be available here.

Here we provide side by side comparison between IDBI Capital vs TradingBell, Below comparison of IDBI Capital vs TradingBell highlights the variations of Brokerage charges & services offered, Compare their ratings, brokerage & AMC charges, Investment choices, Customer Service, Demat Account, features, Platforms, and running offers.

One on One comparison of IDBI Capital vs TradingBell is given below:

IDBI Capital TradingBell
About The Brokers
IDBI Capital :

"The IDBI capital is the wholly owned subsidiary of the IDBI Bank Ltd. and was established in 1992. They are full-service broker and provide the 3-in-1 trading account   >>> more

TradingBell :

"Trading Bells is a hybrid broker who provides discount & full-service broking both via its differentiated trading plans, wherein standard plan it offers trading facil   >>> more

Find More Information about the Broker :
IDBI Capital :
OVERVIEW BROKERAGE PRODUCTS & SERVICES TRADING PLATFORM & TOOLS RATING
TradingBell :
OVERVIEW BROKERAGE PRODUCTS & SERVICES TRADING PLATFORM & TOOLS RATING
Type of Broker
IDBI Capital :
 Full Service Broker
TradingBell :
 Full Service Broker
Promo/offers
IDBI Capital :
N/A
TradingBell :
N/A
Advantage
IDBI Capital :
  • NRI services available
  • Investment in SIP & Mutual Funds
  • Provide 3-in-1 trading account
  • Versatile trading platforms available
  • Market research report and advice are provided to the investors
TradingBell :
  •  High range of products like other brokers.
  •  Flat rs.20 as brokerage charge is the cheapest all across India.
  •  Zero brokerage for equity trading. Swastika Investment Ltd. is there to backup is any loss happens; strong roots.
  •  After market orders , free automated trading is available with Tradingbells.
  •  Demo/virtual trading available.
  •  Online account opening in 15 minutes.
  •  NRI Services
Disadvantage
IDBI Capital :
  • Do not provide a few financial products such as commodity & currency trading
  • Minimum brokerage charges are high
  • High Brokerage
  • Analytical tools are available but with the subscription fee.
  • It does not provide Terminal Based trading tool
TradingBell :
  •   Rs.20 Charged extra for each executed order in Call and Trade.
  •   Tradingbells charges Annual Maintenance Cost (AMC) for DEMAT account but in case most of the brokers don't.
  •   No innovative tools and technology.
  •   Lack of information on the website.
Why This
IDBI Capital :
  • Investment offering to NRIs.
  • Allows you to link your existing saving account to the IDBI trading account
  • Provide 3-in-1 trading account
  • Provide flexible and multiple brokerage plans.
  • Provides margin and e-margin facility to their clients.
TradingBell :
    •  24*7 Web base back office support.
    •  Proper technical analysis and research team.
    •  100+ own branches.
    •  IPO's and IPO financing.
    •  More than 700 business partners and sub brokers.
    •  Portfolio management & Investment Advisory Services.

IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Account Opening & AMC Charges

IDBI Capital Trading Account Opening Fee is ₹500 and TradingBell Trading Account Opening Fee is ₹300 Equity | ₹200 Commodity . IDBI Capital Demat Account AMC is ₹450 and TradingBell Demat Account AMC is ₹300 .

IDBI Capital TradingBell
Trading Account Opening Fee Trading Account Opening Fee :

₹500

Trading Account Opening Fee :

₹300 Equity | ₹200 Commodity

Demat Account Opening Fee Demat Account Opening Fee :

NIL

Demat Account Opening Fee :

₹150

Demat Account AMC Demat Account AMC :

₹450

Demat Account AMC :

₹300

Trading Account AMC Trading Account AMC :

₹0

Trading Account AMC :

NIL


IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Brokerage Charges

IDBI Capital Brokerage Charges Equity Delivery is 0.10% to 0.50% and Equity Intraday is 0.020% to 0.050% and Equity Options is ₹100 per lot . TradingBell Brokerage Charges Equity Delivery is ₹0 (Free) and Equity Intraday is ₹20 per trade and Equity Options is ₹20 per trade .

IDBI Capital TradingBell
Plan Name Plan Name :

Paisa Power Classic

Plan Name :

IDBI Capital Ace Trader Plan

Plan Name :

TradingBell

Equity Delivery Equity Delivery :

0.10% to 0.50%

Equity Delivery :

0.50%

Equity Delivery :

₹0 (Free)

Equity Intraday Equity Intraday :

0.020% to 0.050%

Equity Intraday :

0.05%

Equity Intraday :

₹20 per trade

Equity Future Equity Future :

0.020% to 0.048%

Equity Future :

0.05%

Equity Future :

₹20 per trade

Equity Options Equity Options :

₹100 per lot

Equity Options :

₹100 per lot

Equity Options :

₹20 per trade

Currency Futures Currency Futures : - Currency Futures :

NA

Currency Futures :

₹20 per trade

Currency Options Currency Options : - Currency Options :

NA

Currency Options :

₹20 per trade

Monthly Fee Monthly Fee : - Monthly Fee : - Monthly Fee :

Nil

Margin Trading Margin Trading : - Margin Trading : - Margin Trading : -
Commodity Futures Commodity Futures : - Commodity Futures :

NA

Commodity Futures :

₹20 per trade

Commodity Options Commodity Options : - Commodity Options :

NA

Commodity Options : -

IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Transaction Charges (Per Crore)

IDBI Capital Transaction Charges (Per Crore) Equity Future is 0.0019% and Equity Options is 0.051% on premium . TradingBell Transaction Charges (Per Crore) Equity Future is NSE ₹210 per crore | BSE ₹70 per crore (each side) and Equity Options is NSE ₹6000 per crore | BSE ₹3000 per crore (each side) (on premium) .

IDBI Capital TradingBell
Equity Delivery Equity Delivery :

0.00325%

Equity Delivery :

NSE ₹325 per crore | BSE ₹275 per crore (each side

Equity Intraday Equity Intraday :

0.00325%

Equity Intraday :

NSE ₹325 per crore | BSE ₹275 per crore (each side

Equity Future * Equity Future :

0.0019%

Equity Future :

NSE ₹210 per crore | BSE ₹70 per crore (each side)

Equity Options * Equity Options :

0.051% on premium

Equity Options :

NSE ₹6000 per crore | BSE ₹3000 per crore (each side) (on premium)

Currency Futures * Currency Futures :

NA

Currency Futures :

NSE ₹135 per crore (0.00135%)

Currency Options Currency Options :

NA

Currency Options :

NSE ₹4400 (on premium) per crore (0.044%)

Commodity Commodity :

NA

Commodity :

Non-Agri ₹310 (0.0036%) | Agri (NCDEX) ₹400 per Cr


IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Other Charges

IDBI Capital Minimum Brokerage is ₹25 per trade or 2.5% of the trade value whichever is lower. and Call & Trade is Nil . TradingBell Minimum Brokerage is ₹0 and Call & Trade is Additional ₹20 per executed order .

IDBI Capital TradingBell
Minimum Brokerage Minimum Brokerage :

₹25 per trade or 2.5% of the trade value whichever is lower.

Minimum Brokerage :

₹0

Call & Trade Call & Trade :

Nil

Call & Trade :

Additional ₹20 per executed order

Stamp Duty * Stamp Duty :

Charges as per the state of residence

Stamp Duty :

Charges as per the state of residence

DP Charges (on sell side) DP Charges (on sell side) :

0.04% of transaction value (minimum ₹30)

DP Charges (on sell side) :

Null

Other Miscellaneous Charges Other Miscellaneous Charges : - Other Miscellaneous Charges :

Brokerage charge is 0.01% or Rs 20 per executed order, whichever is lower.


IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Features

IDBI Capital and TradingBell both offer a host of features, trading tools & platforms to their clients. Their comparative analysis is in the below table:

IDBI Capital TradingBell
Trading Platform Trading Platform :

Power Pro

Trading Platform :

NSE NOW, ODIN, JUSTRADE

Placing orders through charts Placing orders through charts :

No

Placing orders through charts :

Yes

Trading Alerts Trading Alerts :

No

Trading Alerts : -
Research and Advice / Trading Tips Research and Advice / Trading Tips : - Research and Advice / Trading Tips :

1

Detailed Education Initiatives Detailed Education Initiatives :

No

Detailed Education Initiatives :

No

Unique features & Offers Unique features & Offers :

Morning report, Equity SIP, Investment Guide

Unique features & Offers : -
Referral Program Referral Program : - Referral Program : -
Margin Against Shares (Equity Cash) * Margin Against Shares (Equity Cash) :

Yes

Margin Against Shares (Equity Cash) :

Yes

Margin Against Shares (Equity F&O) * Margin Against Shares (Equity F&O) :

Yes

Margin Against Shares (Equity F&O) :

Yes


IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Demat Account Charges

A comparative table of various demat account charges between IDBI Capital and TradingBell is below:

IDBI Capital TradingBell
Depository Service Provider Depository Service Provider :

NSDL and CDSL

Depository Service Provider :

CDSL & NSDL

Account Opening Fee Account Opening Fee :

₹500

Account Opening Fee :

₹300 Equity | ₹200 Commodity

Advance Deposit Advance Deposit : - Advance Deposit :

Nil

AMC AMC :

NIL

AMC :

Nil

Dematerialisation Charges Dematerialisation Charges :

Flat ₹5 per certificates

Dematerialisation Charges :

(A) ₹2/- per certificate (Minimum ₹10/-) Plus postal charges.

(B) BSDA-UP TO 50000 - ₹5/- Per cer (Min. ₹50/-)

(C) BSDA 50000 to 200000 - ₹5/- Per cer (Min. ₹50/-)

Rematerialisation Charges Rematerialisation Charges :

20 per certificates

Rematerialisation Charges :

(A)₹12/- per 100 shares or part thereof, OR, ₹50/- per certificate + CDSL charges

(B) BSDA-UP TO 50000 - ₹50 (CDSL Charges Extra)

(C) BSDA 50000 to 200000 - ₹50 (CDSL Charges Extra)

Transaction Charges (Credit) Transaction Charges (Credit) : - Transaction Charges (Credit) : -
Transaction Charges (debit) Transaction Charges (debit) :

₹10 per scrip

Transaction Charges (debit) : -
Pledge Creation Charges Pledge Creation Charges :

0.02% of the value of the scrip (Min ₹25)

Pledge Creation Charges :

₹25 per security

Pledge Creation Confirmation Charges Pledge Creation Confirmation Charges : - Pledge Creation Confirmation Charges :

₹25 per security

Pledge Invocation Charges Pledge Invocation Charges :

0.15% of the value of the scrip (Min ₹25)

Pledge Invocation Charges :

₹25 per security

Failed Instruction Charges Failed Instruction Charges : - Failed Instruction Charges :

₹50 per instruction

Other Charges Other Charges :

A/c Freezing / Defreezing: ₹100

Other Charges :

(A) Account De-Freezing ₹100/-.

(B) Cheque Bounce Charges: ₹500 per bounced cheque

(C) Rejection of Dematerialization Request Form: ₹25

Client Details Modification: ₹25

  • KRA Upload/Download: ₹50 per request

  • IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Basic Details

    IDBI Capital Year of Incorporation is 1993 and Total Number of Clients is 50510 and Total Number of Branches is 14 . TradingBell and Total Number of Clients is 26900 and .

    IDBI Capital TradingBell
    Year of Incorporation Year of Incorporation :

    1993

    Year of Incorporation : -
    Active Exchange Memberships Active Exchange Memberships :

    NSE, BSE

    Active Exchange Memberships :

    BSE, NSE, MCX, NCDEX

    Demat Services Demat Services :

    Yes

    Demat Services :

    Donot Know

    Website Website :

    https://www.idbidirect.in

    Website :

    https://tradingbells.com/

    Contact Details Contact Details :

    022-39135001

    Contact Details :

    9667658800

    Total Number of Clients Total Number of Clients :

    50510

    Total Number of Clients :

    26900

    Total Number of Branches Total Number of Branches :

    14

    Total Number of Branches : -
    Products * Products : - Products : -

    IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Leverage

    Leverage

    IDBI Capital TradingBell
    Equity Delivery Equity Delivery :

    Nil

    Equity Delivery :

    1x

    Equity Intraday Equity Intraday :

    Upto 4x

    Equity Intraday :

    10x for most scripts

    Equity Futures Equity Futures :

    Nil

    Equity Futures :

    Intraday: 3x | Carry: 1x

    Equity Options Equity Options :

    Nil

    Equity Options :

    1x

    Currency Futures Currency Futures :

    Nil

    Currency Futures :

    Intraday: 3x | Carry: 1x

    Currency Options Currency Options :

    Nil

    Currency Options :

    Intraday: 3x | Carry: 1x

    Commodity Futures Commodity Futures :

    Nil

    Commodity Futures :

    Intraday: 3x | Carry: 1x

    Commodity Options Commodity Options : - Commodity Options : -
    F&O (Eq, Curr, Comm) F&O (Eq, Curr, Comm) : - F&O (Eq, Curr, Comm) : -

    IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Orders

    Orders

    IDBI Capital TradingBell
    Cover Orders (CO) Cover Orders (CO) :

    No

    Cover Orders (CO) : -
    Bracket orders / One Cancels Other (BO / OCO) Bracket orders / One Cancels Other (BO / OCO) :

    No

    Bracket orders / One Cancels Other (BO / OCO) : -
    After Market Orders (AMO) After Market Orders (AMO) :

    No

    After Market Orders (AMO) : -
    Buy Today Sell Tomorrow (BTST) * Buy Today Sell Tomorrow (BTST) :

    Yes

    Buy Today Sell Tomorrow (BTST) :

    Yes

    Sell Today Buy Tomorrow (STBT) * Sell Today Buy Tomorrow (STBT) :

    Yes

    Sell Today Buy Tomorrow (STBT) :

    Yes

    Good Till Cancelled (GTC) * Good Till Cancelled (GTC) :

    Yes

    Good Till Cancelled (GTC) :

    Yes


    IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Research and Advice / Trading Tips

    Research and Advice / Trading Tips

    IDBI Capital TradingBell
    Equity Trading Recommendation * Equity Trading Recommendation : - Equity Trading Recommendation : -
    Equity Investment Recommendation * Equity Investment Recommendation : - Equity Investment Recommendation : -
    Recommendation basis risk Profile * Recommendation basis risk Profile : - Recommendation basis risk Profile : -
    Comparison * Comparison : - Comparison : -
    Free Tips * Free Tips : - Free Tips : -
    Daily Market report * Daily Market report : - Daily Market report : -
    ETF research * ETF research : - ETF research : -
    Quarterly Results * Quarterly Results : - Quarterly Results : -

    IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Franchisee / Authorized Person related information

    Franchisee / Authorized Person related information

    IDBI Capital TradingBell
    Availability for franchisee / AP Availability for franchisee / AP :

    Yes

    Availability for franchisee / AP :

    Yes

    Investment required for Franchisee / AP Investment required for Franchisee / AP :

    Rs.50,000 to Rs.3,00,000

    Investment required for Franchisee / AP :

    Min.- Rs. 25,000


    IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Product & Services

    IDBI Capital and TradingBell both offer a host of Products & Services for a better trading experience for their clients. Their comparative analysis is in the below table:

    IDBI Capital TradingBell
    Delivery Based Trading * Delivery Based Trading : - Delivery Based Trading : -
    Margin Trading * Margin Trading : - Margin Trading : -
    Call in Trade * Call in Trade : - Call in Trade : -
    Trading in Both the exchanges * Trading in Both the exchanges : - Trading in Both the exchanges : -
    Limit Order * Limit Order : - Limit Order : -
    3-in-1 On-line Trading Account * 3-in-1 On-line Trading Account : - 3-in-1 On-line Trading Account : -
    NRI Services * NRI Services : - NRI Services : -
    SMS Alerts * SMS Alerts : - SMS Alerts : -
    Offers Multiple Plan * Offers Multiple Plan : - Offers Multiple Plan : -
    IPO Investment * IPO Investment : - IPO Investment : -
    Portfolio Analysis * Portfolio Analysis : - Portfolio Analysis : -
    Advanced Charting Features * Advanced Charting Features : - Advanced Charting Features : -
    Brokerage Calculator * Brokerage Calculator : - Brokerage Calculator : -
    Margin Calculator * Margin Calculator : - Margin Calculator : -
    Stop Loss Order * Stop Loss Order : - Stop Loss Order : -
    Bracket Orders & Trailing Stop Loss * Bracket Orders & Trailing Stop Loss : - Bracket Orders & Trailing Stop Loss : -
    Equity Future & Option Trading * Equity Future & Option Trading : - Equity Future & Option Trading : -
    Currency Future & Option Trading * Currency Future & Option Trading : - Currency Future & Option Trading : -
    Market Trading * Market Trading : - Market Trading : -
    Monthly & Yearly Plan * Monthly & Yearly Plan : - Monthly & Yearly Plan : -
    Aumtomated Trading * Aumtomated Trading : - Aumtomated Trading : -

    IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Customer Services

    IDBI Capital and TradingBell both offer a host of Customer service options to their clients to quickly solve their queries or grievances if any. Their comparative analysis is in the below table:

    IDBI Capital TradingBell
    Toll Free Number * Toll Free Number : - Toll Free Number : -
    Live Chat Facility * Live Chat Facility : - Live Chat Facility : -
    Email Facility * Email Facility : - Email Facility : -
    Branch Offices * Branch Offices : - Branch Offices : -
    Customer Care * Customer Care : - Customer Care : -
    Community Service * Community Service : - Community Service : -
    Relationship Manager * Relationship Manager : - Relationship Manager : -
    24/7 Support * 24/7 Support : - 24/7 Support : -

    IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Other Investement

    IDBI Capital and TradingBell both offer a lot of investment avenues apart from Stock trading on their platforms to their clients to make a better trading experience. Their comparative analysis is in the below table:

    IDBI Capital TradingBell
    Commodity Trading * Commodity Trading : - Commodity Trading : -
    Investment in ETFs * Investment in ETFs : - Investment in ETFs : -
    Investment in Mutual Funds * Investment in Mutual Funds : - Investment in Mutual Funds : -
    Investment in Bonds * Investment in Bonds : - Investment in Bonds : -
    Investment in Corporate Debt instruments * Investment in Corporate Debt instruments : - Investment in Corporate Debt instruments : -
    Insurance Services * Insurance Services : - Insurance Services : -
    Banking Services * Banking Services : - Banking Services : -

    IDBI Capital vs TradingBell Trading PlatForm

    IDBI Capital and TradingBell both offer a host of Trading Platform for a better trading experience for their clients. Their comparative analysis is in the below table:

    IDBI Capital TradingBell
    Web Platform * Web Platform : - Web Platform : -
    Android Mobile App * Android Mobile App : - Android Mobile App : -
    Desktop Windows * Desktop Windows : - Desktop Windows : -
    Desktop Mac * Desktop Mac : - Desktop Mac : -
    I-Pad App * I-Pad App : - I-Pad App : -
    Virtual Trading * Virtual Trading : - Virtual Trading : -
    iPhone Mobile App * iPhone Mobile App : - iPhone Mobile App : -
    Contact Now Enquire Now Enquire Now

    User Reviews

    Post New Message
    0  Comments
    - - -   Compare More Brokers   - - -
    IDBI CapitalTradingBell
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Zerodha
     Compare IDBI Capital vs ICICI Direct
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Upstox
     Compare IDBI Capital vs HDFC Securities
     Compare IDBI Capital vs MyValueTrade
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Sharekhan
     Compare IDBI Capital vs SAMCO
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Axis Direct
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Trade Smart
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Kotak Securities
     Compare IDBI Capital vs SAS Online
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Angel Broking
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Motilal Oswal
     Compare IDBI Capital vs 5paisa
     Compare IDBI Capital vs ProStocks
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Geojit BNP Paribas
     Compare IDBI Capital vs SBICAP Securities
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Mangal Keshav
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Marwadi Group
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Mastertrust
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Mdirect
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Achiievers
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Networth Direct
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Nirmal Bang
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Reliance Securities
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Religare Broking
     Compare IDBI Capital vs LSE Securities
     Compare IDBI Capital vs SMC Global
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Sushil Finance
     Compare IDBI Capital vs TradingBell
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Paytm Money
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Ventura
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Alice Blue
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Stoxkart
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Dhani Stocks
     Compare IDBI Capital vs GEPL Capital
     Compare IDBI Capital vs RKGlobal
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Aditya Birla Money
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Anand Rathi
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Compositedge
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Arihant Capital
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Bonanza Portfolio
     Compare IDBI Capital vs TradePlus
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Edelweiss
     Compare IDBI Capital vs GCL Securities
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Fyers
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Wisdom Capital
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Groww
     Compare IDBI Capital vs IIFL
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Indiabulls Ventures
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Just Trade
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Karvy
     Compare IDBI Capital vs Tradejini
     Compare TradingBell vs Zerodha
     Compare TradingBell vs ICICI Direct
     Compare TradingBell vs Upstox
     Compare TradingBell vs HDFC Securities
     Compare TradingBell vs MyValueTrade
     Compare TradingBell vs Sharekhan
     Compare TradingBell vs SAMCO
     Compare TradingBell vs Axis Direct
     Compare TradingBell vs Trade Smart
     Compare TradingBell vs Kotak Securities
     Compare TradingBell vs SAS Online
     Compare TradingBell vs Angel Broking
     Compare TradingBell vs Motilal Oswal
     Compare TradingBell vs 5paisa
     Compare TradingBell vs ProStocks
     Compare TradingBell vs Geojit BNP Paribas
     Compare TradingBell vs SBICAP Securities
     Compare TradingBell vs Mangal Keshav
     Compare TradingBell vs Marwadi Group
     Compare TradingBell vs Mastertrust
     Compare TradingBell vs Mdirect
     Compare TradingBell vs Achiievers
     Compare TradingBell vs Networth Direct
     Compare TradingBell vs Nirmal Bang
     Compare TradingBell vs Reliance Securities
     Compare TradingBell vs Religare Broking
     Compare TradingBell vs LSE Securities
     Compare TradingBell vs SMC Global
     Compare TradingBell vs Sushil Finance
     Compare TradingBell vs Paytm Money
     Compare TradingBell vs Ventura
     Compare TradingBell vs Alice Blue
     Compare TradingBell vs Stoxkart
     Compare TradingBell vs Dhani Stocks
     Compare TradingBell vs GEPL Capital
     Compare TradingBell vs RKGlobal
     Compare TradingBell vs Aditya Birla Money
     Compare TradingBell vs Anand Rathi
     Compare TradingBell vs Compositedge
     Compare TradingBell vs Arihant Capital
     Compare TradingBell vs Bonanza Portfolio
     Compare TradingBell vs TradePlus
     Compare TradingBell vs Edelweiss
     Compare TradingBell vs GCL Securities
     Compare TradingBell vs Fyers
     Compare TradingBell vs Wisdom Capital
     Compare TradingBell vs Groww
     Compare TradingBell vs IDBI Capital
     Compare TradingBell vs IIFL
     Compare TradingBell vs Indiabulls Ventures
     Compare TradingBell vs Just Trade
     Compare TradingBell vs Karvy
     Compare TradingBell vs Tradejini